
I'm not completely put off by the thought of Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law as Holmes and Watson respectively. In that respect Guy Ritchie got it fairly right as far as age is concerned. In the first Sherlock Holmes stories, both Holmes and Watson are actually around the age of 27. Although, this would make both actors too old to play the part seeing that Robert Downey Jr. is 43 and Jude Law is 36. But in the grand scheme of things they're young guys. So, let's not split hairs.
Although, here's a tidbit of information for you all. One of Jude Law's earliest acting appearances was all the way back in 1991 in an episode of
The Casebook of Sherlock Holmes. The episode was
Shoscombe Old Place which starred the ultimate Sherlock Holmes Jeremy Brett.
I happen to like Jude Law. I thought he gave a really great performance as Lord Alfred 'Bosie' Douglas in the film
Wilde. That was the movie that kind of won me over for his acting chops. Sort of the same way
Chaplin won me over for Robert Downey Jr.'s acting.
Strangely enough, both films are bio's.
But with this said, I think this is probably the most unusual Holmes and Watson since Nicol Williamson and Robert Duvall were Holmes and Watson in
The Seven-Per-Cent Solution.
And yes. You read that right. Robert Duvall as Watson.
I don't know much about the series of comic books by Lionel Wigram this upcoming movie is based upon. So, I really can't give an opinion on something I haven't seen or know nothing about.
I suppose from a marketing standpoint, I understand Guy Ritchie's choice for Holmes. There's no bigger name in Hollywood that is in demand other than Robert Downey Jr. at this very moment. And like I said, he's an actor I really like. And I'm happy he has cleaned up his life and he's getting the respect and the attention he deserves.
But here's my feelings. I think a lot of books and movies take a huge risk at trying to make Sherlock Holmes more dynamic. Because it can either work brilliantly or it can blow up in your face.
A good case in point is the movie
A Study in Terror which starred John Neville as a more youthful Sherlock Holmes than most moviegoers were use to seeing with the tagline:
"Sherlock Holmes meets Jack the Ripper! Here comes the original caped crusader!"Both Batman T.V. series and James Bond were massively popular at the time. So, the producers were really heavily marketing it on that angle.
And it's a great film!! It didn't do good originally in the box offices. But it's one of my favorite Sherlock Holmes films.
The reason I feel this movie works is because despite stuff like making Holmes a man of action and even giving him a knife which pops out the end of his walking stick, the producers stick close to the original character of Sherlock Holmes. They still remain true to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's character while making him
James Bond with a cape.
An example of reinventing Holmes that went horribly, horribly wrong is 2002's USA Networks production
Sherlock also titled
A Case of Evil starring James D'Arcy. It's yet another attempt to do a Young Sherlock Holmes type movie. The producers also saw it fit to give their Young Sherlock a sex drive and make Dr. Watson an eccentric inventor.
How could you possibly go wrong with that? Well, you could and it did!! The movie was awful. AND once again you have Richard E. Grant horribly miscasted as Mycroft Holmes.
As I have stated before I thing REG should be the one playing Sherlock Holmes in most of the productions he has been a part of.
But it's an example of how reinventing the character can make for a really bad film. In this particular film's case, it tried to completely reinvent the whole history of Sherlock Holmes.
With all that said, I'm willing to give Guy Ritchie's film a chance. Mostly because that part of me that likes to see how someone approaches the character of Sherlock Holmes. Good or bad, I like to see how actors approach the character.
Here's another historical fact for you all before I close this blog. When William Gillette took his play
Sherlock Holmes to England, the young boy who played Billy the Page on stage was a young Master Charles Spencer Chaplin...
...who Robert Downey Jr. portrayed.